Graeme M
Forum Legend
Vegansurveyor, how much do you care about being labelled a "vegan". If that is important to you, then you need to find the purest interpretation from the purest vegan and work from there. Or you could view veganism as an idea about how to make the best ethical choices. In your case, the question is how far you think one should take the matter of animal rights. In fact I think you need to work out what you even mean by the concept. Animals do not have rights naturally - "rights" is a convenient way to describe the idea that we formalise the relationship we have with them. And because we are the ones doing that, we get to decide just what rights should be extended.For people like me, who are vegan for the sake of animal rights, eating a dead animal is not the problem; killing it is. So I am fine with eating lab-grown meat once it arrives on the shelves in my country, and would still considered myself vegan if I did. I imagine many vegans centered on animal rights would think the same way. However, there are people who are vegan for health reasons, and in their view, eating cultured meat would classify me as non-vegan. Do you believe that eating cultured meat would make an otherwise vegan person non-vegan? And if a great number of vegans decide to eat cultured meat, how are we going to deal with the inevitable confusion surrounding the term "vegan"?
Given you don't agree with killing other animals, it seems cultured meat gets a tick there. Taking the cells from a living being without their consent would seem to violate their rights (with the above caveat), but I assume that if you have a pet you are happy to treat them in all sorts of ways without their consent, starting with their imprisonment. Given the benefits of cultured meat in terms of saving animal lives and reducing impacts on the environment by reducing the need for agricultural land, I think the invasive nature probably can get a tick as it is certainly no worse than things vegans already do to other animals every day.
The matter of eating flesh is not veganism, it is sentimentalism. People have eaten other humans. If you like meat and you are willing to accept that cultured meat is within your world view, then it is OK to eat it. And support it.
Veganism isn't a club. It's a way of thinking about how to make choices about behaviour. Who cares what Donald Watson thinks, it isn't his call what you do.