400lbs-Starting a natural vegan diet.
- Thread starter Sadlittlesunflower
- Start date
I agree with most of what Jeff says I just don't appreciate his "I am right" attitude and people like Dr Gregor are wrong.... everyone has a contribution.
Emma JC
Find your vegan soulmate or just a friend. www.spiritualmatchmaking.com
Emma JC
Find your vegan soulmate or just a friend. www.spiritualmatchmaking.com
Agreed, the bickering is unnecessary, but maybe they think the polemic between the two camps helps spreading the more important part of the message which is, go plant based.
Last edited:
Hello all, many smart things have already been said here, in addition just the old piece of wisdom that going vegan in itself is by no means a diet, you also need to measure your food intake.
And the best « crash diet » might not work if you can not keep it up.
And the best « crash diet » might not work if you can not keep it up.
BTW not to be hypocrite on this issue I do have the impression, maybe wrong, that doctor Gregor reads studies without critical judgement, besides Jeff debunking several studies, my former dentist who is also a college teacher and very rigorous about these things denied a the information in one of his podcasts about teeth cavities and there is also the video below of doctor Neal Barnard actually analysing a study doctor Gregor cites and coming to a different conclusion.
And of course people should point out the points in which they disagree.
Last edited:
Brian W
Conscientious Christian
Cut your fats, salt and sugar, get plenty of fiber in the form of wholefoods, exercise regularly and brush your teeth. That's the basics. When you get too engrossed in details you fall down rabbit holes and find a ton of pointless arguments and debates with no clear answers. Make it easy on yourself and don't obsess about food then you will have time, energy and headspace free with which to live.
That sounds like wise advice. What's brushing the teeth got to do with a healthy vegan diet?
Brian W
Conscientious Christian
What has exercise got to do with a healthy vegan diet? I just wanted to show the simplicity of a healthy life generally - of course we do that without animal products.
Brian W
Conscientious Christian
Yeah, I was comparing your question to something else I wrote that you didn't mention. The answer is, of course, the same.No, it was brushing your teeth. I suppose the answer will be the same.
Lou
Forum Legend
Yeah, the brushing your teeth seems sort of random. What about flossing? Or regular visits to the Doctor?
But exercise seems like a good thing to mention in this context. Dr. Grager even includes it in his Daily Dozen.
And it makes sense too. In order to get adequate nutrition you need to eat adequate food. If you don't exercise you can't eat as much food without gaining weight.
Of course exercise is not unique to a WFPB diet. The percentage of protein over calories is going to be lower in a WFPB diet, compared to a non-vegan diet. So in order to get similar amounts of protein you may need to eat more calories.
my point was that maybe Dr Gregor isn't perfect, maybe Dr Bernard isn't either (although he is very very handsome lol), and I know that back in the early 2010's I tried to go vegan using Dr Esselstyn's information and it didn't work for me - that doesn't mean that what he and his family do should be complained about - Jeff has made a lot of mistakes himself over the past 8 years that I have watched him (although not recently) and I just think he could have been able to get his message across without the dissing of others - most of what Jeff said has come from Dr McDougall and that's fine as he is the person that was responsible for myself and my honey finally sticking to a whole food plant based diet and yet he doesn't 'do it' for many other people - all paths that lead to less animals being consumed and harmed is fine with me and as he said there is no need to nit pick and try to be perfect... as the body is very adaptable
Emma JC
Find your vegan soulmate or just a friend. www.spiritualmatchmaking.com
Emma JC
Find your vegan soulmate or just a friend. www.spiritualmatchmaking.com
Lou
Forum Legend
Most of the time when there are opposing viewpoints the best answer is a combination of the two. In this case maybe a combination of more than two.
I'm firmly in the Gregar/ Fuhrman camp. but I take away and use information from Bernard, McDougal, and Esselstyn, too
Oh, I just remembered this.. and I am pleasantly surprised that after all these years I was able to find it so quickly.
From this color coded chart you can see that Most vegan Diets are Mostly the same. just differences in emphasis
Although I don't think the data is 100% correct.
growsewhappy.wordpress.com
I'm firmly in the Gregar/ Fuhrman camp. but I take away and use information from Bernard, McDougal, and Esselstyn, too
Oh, I just remembered this.. and I am pleasantly surprised that after all these years I was able to find it so quickly.
From this color coded chart you can see that Most vegan Diets are Mostly the same. just differences in emphasis
Although I don't think the data is 100% correct.
Diet Comparison Chart
It all kind of started with eggs. They were one of the last things that I finally took out of our diet so we could be completely vegan… but I’d always intuitively felt that they were healthy, and I…
growsewhappy.wordpress.com
Brian W
Conscientious Christian
It wasn't random, it was because of a video somebody posted concerning a debate over tooth cavities. My post was about the basics being simple and flossing doesn't come into the basics. It might be more ideal but a lot of people don't do it and don't have problems. Regular visits to the doctor won't keep you healthy either and is an irrelevant distraction from what I was trying to say. It isn't about doctors and medicine that most people don't need most of the time, it is about what I do in my life to maintain good health.
My bad, I shouldn't have posted such a divisive video.
I keep being sucked to the the world of duality.
